Catfishing, the act of luring someone into a relationship by creating a fake online persona, has become an increasingly common phenomenon in the digital age. While many view catfishing as a cruel and deceptive practice, the legal implications of this behaviour are not always clear, particularly in New South Wales (NSW), Australia.

This article aims to shed light on the legal status of catfishing in NSW, exploring when and how it may cross the line into criminal behaviour. By examining relevant laws, such as those related to fraud, child exploitation, and using a carriage service for unlawful purposes, we will provide a comprehensive overview of the potential legal consequences of catfishing. Armed with this knowledge, readers will be better equipped to understand their rights and protect themselves from falling victim to this increasingly common form of online deception.

Understanding Catfishing Under NSW Law

Catfishing, the act of luring someone into a relationship using a fake online persona, is a growing concern in the digital age. While not all instances of catfishing are illegal, certain behaviours associated with this practice can cross the line into criminal territory under NSW law.

What Constitutes Catfishing in NSW

In NSW, there is no specific law against catfishing among adults. Using a fake identity online to meet another adult is not inherently a crime, similar to using a false name on a blind date. However, the actions that stem from catfishing can be illegal, particularly when they involve fraud, threats, or the exploitation of minors.

The act of catfishing itself is often cruel and can cause significant emotional distress to victims, but it falls into a legal grey area unless it involves additional criminal elements. NSW law does not currently have provisions to prosecute catfishing solely on the grounds of emotional manipulation or deception in adult relationships.

When Catfishing Becomes a Criminal Offence

Catfishing crosses the line into criminal behaviour when it involves specific illegal actions, such as:

1. Fraud: If the catfisher uses deception to obtain money or property from the victim, they can be charged with fraud under Section 192E of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). This requires proving that the victim suffered a financial disadvantage due to the catfisher’s intentional or reckless deception.
2. Procuring or grooming minors: It is a serious crime to use catfishing to procure or groom children under 16 for unlawful sexual activity. Section 66EB of the Crimes Act outlines penalties of up to 12–15 years in prison for adults who use online means to encourage minors to engage in sexual acts.
3. Stalking or intimidation: Repeated online contact that causes fear or distress may constitute stalking or intimidation offences under the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW).
4. Sharing intimate images: Threatening to share or actually sharing intimate images obtained through catfishing could be prosecuted under NSW’s ‘revenge porn’ laws.

In these situations, the catfishing itself is not the primary offence, but rather a means to commit other crimes. The law focuses on the harmful actions and consequences rather than the act of creating a fake online persona.

It’s important to note that while NSW does not have specific laws criminalising catfishing among adults, there are growing calls to introduce such legislation. Some argue that catfishing should be illegal due to its cruel and deceptive nature, even when no financial incentive is involved. However, others say that existing criminal laws are sufficient to prosecute the most harmful catfishing behaviours.

If you have been the victim of catfishing that involved fraud, threats, or the sharing of intimate images, you should report it to the police. If the catfishing involved emotional manipulation but no clear criminal offence, you may still be able to seek support services or report the fake profile to the relevant social media platform.

Criminal Offences Associated with Catfishing in NSW

Fraud and Financial Deception

Catfishing can constitute fraud under Section 192E of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) when it involves obtaining a financial advantage or causing a financial disadvantage through deception. For the offence to be established, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that:

1. By deception, the defendant acted dishonestly, and
2. These actions created a financial advantage over another person’s property, or caused them to suffer a financial disadvantage, and
3. The actions were intentional or reckless.

The maximum penalty for fraud is ten years’ imprisonment if the matter is dealt with in the District Court, or two years if it remains in the Local Court.

Child Exploitation and Grooming Offences

Using catfishing to target and exploit minors can lead to serious criminal charges under Section 66EB of the Crimes Act. An adult who intentionally “procures” or “grooms” a child under 16 for unlawful sexual activity is guilty of an offence.

“Procuring” requires proof that the adult intended to encourage, entice, recruit or induce a child to engage in unlawful sexual activity. In catfishing cases, the prosecution must negate any reasonable possibility that the defendant had a non-sexual intention, despite sexualised communications.

“Grooming” occurs when an adult exposes a child to indecent material or provides them with an intoxicating substance, intending to make it easier to procure the child for unlawful sexual activity. Consent is not a defence under this section.

The maximum penalties range from 10 to 15 years imprisonment, with higher penalties when the child is under 14.

Using a Carriage Service for Criminal Purposes

Carly’s Law, found in Section 474.25C of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth), makes it an offence for any adult to use a carriage service (like the internet or phone) to prepare or plan to cause harm, procure or engage in sexual activity with a person under 16.

This law was introduced after the tragic murder of 15-year-old Carly Ryan by an online predator who used over 200 fake online profiles to lure underage girls.

The maximum penalty under Carly’s Law is 10 years imprisonment. Shortly after its enactment, it was used to charge an Adelaide man for using fake online identities to procure children and commit other child exploitation offences.

Legal Protections for Victims of Catfishing

Victims of catfishing in NSW have several legal protections and remedies available to them, depending on the specific circumstances of their case. It’s important for those who have been catfished to understand their rights and the steps they can take to seek justice and protection.

Reporting Catfishing Incidents

If you’ve been a victim of catfishing, the first step is to report the incident to the relevant authorities. This may include:

1. Police: If the catfishing involved criminal activities such as fraud, stalking, or child exploitation, you should report it to the NSW Police. Provide as much evidence as possible, including screenshots of conversations, financial records, and any other relevant documentation.
2. Australian Cybercrime Online Reporting Network (ACORN): ACORN is a national online system that allows you to securely report cybercrime incidents, including catfishing. Reports made through ACORN are forwarded to the appropriate law enforcement agency for investigation.
3. Social media platforms: If the catfishing occurred on a social media platform like Facebook or Instagram, report the fake profile to the platform’s administrators. Most platforms have built-in reporting mechanisms to flag and remove fraudulent accounts.

Available Legal Remedies

Depending on the nature and severity of the catfishing incident, victims may have several legal remedies available to them under NSW law:

1. Apprehended Violence Orders (AVOs): If the catfishing involved threats, intimidation, or harassment, you may be able to apply for an AVO through the Local Court. An AVO is a court order that prohibits the offender from contacting or approaching you, providing legal protection against further harm.
2. Compensation orders: If the catfishing resulted in financial loss, such as through fraud or scams, the court may order the offender to pay compensation to the victim as part of the criminal sentencing process. Victims can also pursue civil legal action to seek damages for any harm suffered.
3. Injunctions: In some cases, victims may be able to seek an injunction from the court to prevent the catfisher from continuing their deceptive behaviour or to compel them to remove any false or harmful content they have posted online.
4. Victim support services: The NSW government provides a range of support services for victims of crime, including counselling, financial assistance, and legal advice. Victims of catfishing can contact Victims Services NSW to access these resources and support.

It’s important to note that the specific legal remedies available will depend on the individual circumstances of each case. Seeking advice from a qualified legal professional can help victims understand their options and navigate the legal process.

Conclusion

Catfishing is a complex issue that can have serious legal consequences in New South Wales, depending on the specific actions and intentions involved. While there is no standalone criminal offence called “catfishing” in NSW law, certain behaviours associated with catfishing can be prosecuted under existing criminal laws.

Catfishing becomes illegal when it involves fraudulent activities for financial gain, such as obtaining money or property by deception. It can also lead to serious criminal charges when used to procure or groom children under the age of 16 for unlawful sexual activity. In these cases, offenders can face significant penalties, including lengthy prison sentences.

However, when catfishing does not involve fraud or child exploitation, it may not be considered a criminal act, even though it can still cause significant emotional distress to victims. There are growing calls to introduce specific laws to address catfishing and its harmful consequences, but currently, victims may need to rely on other avenues, such as reporting the fake profiles to social media platforms.

Ultimately, the legal landscape around catfishing continues to evolve as our digital lives become increasingly complex. It is crucial for individuals to be aware of the potential risks and consequences of engaging in or falling victim to catfishing schemes. By staying informed and seeking support when needed, we can work towards creating a safer online environment for all.

Your legal peace of mind starts here—contact us for expert advice.

Frequently Asked Questions