Blackmail and extortion are serious criminal offences in New South Wales that can result in significant penalties, including lengthy prison sentences. These offences involve making unwarranted demands with menaces to obtain a gain or cause a loss, or to influence the exercise of a public duty.

If you or someone you know has been charged with blackmail or extortion, it’s crucial to understand the legal definitions, penalties, and available defences for these crimes under the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). This article will provide a comprehensive overview of the law surrounding blackmail and extortion offences in NSW, discussing key legal concepts, maximum penalties, and potential legal defences.

Legal Definition of Blackmail and Extortion in New South Wales

In NSW, the offences of blackmail and extortion are defined under the Crimes Act 1900. Section 249K of the Act outlines the key elements that constitute these crimes.

Elements of Blackmail

A person commits blackmail if they make any unwarranted demand with menaces with the intention of:

• Obtaining a gain or causing a loss, or
• Influencing the exercise of a public duty

The demand must be “unwarranted”, meaning the person making the demand does not reasonably believe they have grounds for making it or that the use of menaces is a proper means of reinforcing the demand.

“Menaces” can include express or implied threats of detrimental action. The threat must be such that it would cause a person of normal stability and courage to act unwillingly in response, or the person making the threat is aware of a particular vulnerability of the victim.

Blackmail carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment. This increases to 14 years if the demand involves a threat to commit a serious indictable offence.

Types of Threats Covered

The threats constituting blackmail can take various forms:

• Express threats – directly stating an intention to cause harm or detriment
• Implied threats – menacing conduct implying detrimental consequences without explicitly stating them
• Threats against individuals – personal threats that would cause a person of normal stability to act unwillingly
• Threats exploiting vulnerabilities – threats tailored to a victim’s particular susceptibilities
• Threats against organisations – menaces that would ordinarily cause an unwilling response from a government or corporate entity

The offence covers a broad spectrum of threatening behaviour, from verbal or written demands to implied consequences arising from the offender’s position of influence. The critical factor is that the threat is used to compel the victim’s compliance with an unwarranted demand.

Legal Penalties for Blackmail and Extortion

Blackmail and extortion offences in NSW carry significant penalties that reflect their serious nature under criminal law. The Crimes Act 1900 prescribes substantial maximum prison terms for those found guilty of these offences.

Maximum Penalties

Under Section 249K, making an unwarranted demand with menaces carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment. This penalty applies when the demand is made with the intention of obtaining a gain, causing a loss, or influencing the exercise of a public duty.

The maximum penalty increases to 14 years imprisonment if the person threatens to commit a serious indictable offence. For example, if someone threatens to commit robbery or assault occasioning actual bodily harm unless their demands are met, they could face this elevated penalty.

The severity of the sentence typically depends on several factors:

• The nature and seriousness of the threats made
• The value of property or benefit demanded
• The vulnerability of the victim
• The offender’s previous criminal history
• Whether the threats were carried out

Courts treat blackmail and extortion as very serious criminal offences, which is reflected in the substantial penalties that may be imposed. Even if no benefit was obtained or the threats were never carried out, a person can still be convicted if there was an intention to obtain gain or cause loss.

Defences Available for Blackmail and Extortion Charges in NSW

When facing blackmail or extortion charges, there are several legal defences that may be available depending on the specific circumstances of the case. Understanding these defences is crucial for anyone accused of these offences, as they can potentially lead to an acquittal or reduction in charges.

Claim of Right

The defence of claim of right applies when the accused person genuinely believes they have a legal entitlement to the property or benefit demanded. For this defence to succeed, the belief must be honest, even if it is not necessarily reasonable.

For example, consider a situation where an individual demands the return of a sum of money they genuinely believe is owed to them by the alleged victim. If the accused can demonstrate that they had an honest belief in their legal right to the money, even if that belief was mistaken, the defence of claim of right may apply.

Duress and Necessity

In some cases, an accused person may argue that they committed the offence of blackmail or extortion under duress or out of necessity. Duress involves situations where the accused was forced to commit the offence due to threats of death or serious injury to themselves or another person.

Necessity, on the other hand, applies when the accused committed the offence to prevent serious harm from occurring, and there was no other reasonable way to prevent that harm. For example, if an individual commits extortion to obtain life-saving medication for a seriously ill family member, the defence of necessity might be raised.

It is important to note that both duress and necessity are complex legal defences that require specific elements to be met. The accused must demonstrate that the threat or circumstances were so severe that a person of ordinary firmness and strength of will would have acted in the same way.

Impact of Technology on Blackmail and Extortion

Modern technology has transformed the landscape of blackmail and extortion offences. Digital platforms and communication tools have created new opportunities for criminals to make unwarranted demands with menaces, particularly through social media and messaging applications.

The rise of digital technology has enabled blackmailers to gather and threaten to expose sensitive personal information more easily. Perpetrators can now make demands and issue threats remotely, often using encrypted communications to avoid detection. This technological evolution has also made it easier to target vulnerable individuals through online platforms.

Online Blackmail and Sextortion

Sextortion has emerged as a prevalent form of online blackmail where perpetrators threaten to publish or distribute intimate videos or images unless their demands are met. This offence is covered under Sections 91P, 91Q and 91R of the Crimes Act 1900.

Digital blackmail can occur through various means, including threatening to expose private information obtained through hacking, social media monitoring, or deceptive online relationships. The anonymity of the internet has made it more challenging for law enforcement to identify and prosecute offenders.

Perpetrators often exploit social media platforms to gather personal information about potential victims. They may use this information to make their threats more credible or to identify particularly vulnerable targets. The immediate and widespread nature of online communication means that threats can be delivered and acted upon rapidly.

The digital nature of modern blackmail presents unique challenges for investigation and prosecution. Evidence may be stored across multiple devices and platforms, requiring specialised forensic techniques to collect and preserve. Additionally, perpetrators may use virtual private networks (VPNs) or other tools to mask their identity and location.

Conclusion

Blackmail and extortion are serious criminal offences in New South Wales that can result in significant legal consequences for those convicted. The Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) outlines the specific elements and penalties associated with these offences, emphasising the importance of understanding the legal framework surrounding these crimes.

By examining the legal definitions, penalties, and potential defences related to blackmail and extortion, this article has provided a comprehensive overview of these offences in NSW. Armed with this knowledge, individuals facing such charges can make informed decisions about their legal options and work with experienced criminal defence lawyers to build a strong case.

Achieve the outcome you deserve—call our experienced attorneys today.

Frequently Asked Questions