Trespass and break and enter are two different but linked crimes in New South Wales law. Both involve entering property without permission, but they come under separate laws and carry different penalties. Understanding the legal distinctions can be vital for property owners, those accused of these crimes, and folks keen to protect their rights.

This comprehensive guide will delve into the specifics of trespass and break and enter offences in NSW. We’ll explore the key elements of each offence, the relevant laws that govern them, and the potential consequences for those found guilty. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of what constitutes trespass and break and enter, how these offences are prosecuted, and what legal defences may be available.

Understanding Trespass Offences in NSW

Trespass offences in NSW are governed by the Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901. This section explains what constitutes trespassing under NSW law and the key elements that must be proven for a trespass offence.

What Constitutes Trespassing Under the Inclosed Lands Protection Act

Under Section 4 of the Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901, a person commits the offence of trespassing if they enter inclosed lands without the consent of the owner, occupier or person in charge of those lands. Trespassing also occurs if a person remains on the property after being requested to leave by the owner or occupier.

‘Inclosed lands’ refers to any land, public or private, that is surrounded by a fence, wall or other erection, or partly by such structures and partly by natural features like rivers or cliffs that define its boundaries. It also includes prescribed premises such as government and non-government schools, child-care services, hospitals and nursing homes.

Types of Trespass Offences

The Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901 outlines several types of trespass offences:

• Unlawful entry on inclosed lands (Section 4)
• Unlawful re-entry on inclosed lands during an organised event (Section 4AA)
• Remaining on inclosed lands and behaving offensively after being asked to leave (Section 4A)
• Aggravated unlawful entry on inclosed lands related to a business or undertaking (Section 4B)
• Directing, inciting, counselling, procuring, commissioning or inducing aggravated unlawful entry on agricultural land (Section 4C)
• Leaving a gate open, either wilfully or negligently (Section 5)

Each of these offences carries different maximum penalties, with aggravated unlawful entry on agricultural lands attracting the most severe punishments.

Penalties for Trespassing

The penalties for trespassing in NSW primarily involve fines, with the amounts varying based on the specific offence:

• Unlawful entry (Section 4): 5 penalty units ($550), or 10 penalty units ($1,100) for prescribed premises
• Unlawful re-entry (Section 4AA): 10 penalty units ($1,100)
• Offensive conduct while remaining on inclosed lands (Section 4A): 10 penalty units ($1,100), or20 penalty units ($2,200) for prescribed premises
• Aggravated unlawful entry (Section 4B): Up to 50 penalty units ($5,500) for non−agricultural land; for agricultural land, up to 120 penalty units ($13,200) and/or 12 months imprisonment, or 200 penalty units ($22,000) and/or 3 years imprisonment if accompanied by 2 or more persons or there was a serious safety risk
• Directing or inducing aggravated unlawful entry (Section 4C): 100 penalty units ($11,000) and/or 12 months imprisonment
• Leaving a gate open (Section 5): 15 penalty units ($1,650)

In certain aggravated circumstances on agricultural lands, trespassing can result in imprisonment of up to 3 years. If a person is found guilty of a trespass offence, it will appear on their criminal record.

Break and Enter Offences Under the Crimes Act

Break and enter offences are more serious than trespass and are covered under the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW). These offences involve unlawfully entering a building or structure with the intent to commit a crime inside.

Elements of Break and Enter Offences

For a break and enter charge to be proven, the prosecution must establish several key elements:

1. Unlawful entry: The accused must have entered the premises without permission or legal justification. This can include entering through an open door or window.
2. Intent to commit a crime: At the time of entry, the accused must have had the intention to commit an indictable offence inside the premises, such as theft or assault.
3. Breaking: Breaking can involve applying force to gain entry, such as breaking a window or lock. However, entry alone can be sufficient if done with intent to commit a crime.

For example, if someone enters a home through an unlocked door with the intention of stealing valuables, this could constitute a break and enter offence even without forced entry.

Different Types of Break and Enter Offences

The Crimes Act outlines several specific breaks and enter offences:

• Break, enter and assault with intent to murder (s110): Entering a dwelling and assaulting someone with the intent to murder or inflict grievous bodily harm. Maximum penalty of 25 years imprisonment.
• Enter dwelling with intent (s111): Entering a dwelling with the intent to commit a serious indictable offence. Maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.
• Break and enter dwelling and commit serious indictable offence (s112): Breaking and entering a dwelling and then committing a serious indictable offence inside. Maximum penalty of 14 years imprisonment.
• Break and enter dwelling with intent (s113): Breaking and entering a dwelling with the intent to commit a serious indictable offence. Maximum penalty of 14 years imprisonment. Aggravated versions carry higher penalties.

These offences are treated very seriously, with most carrying potential penalties of imprisonment. The specific charge will depend on factors like whether the premises was a dwelling, if a serious indictable offence was committed inside, and whether aggravating circumstances were present.

Circumstances of Aggravation

Certain factors can elevate a break and enter offence to an aggravated version, which carries higher maximum penalties. These aggravating circumstances include:

• Being armed with an offensive weapon or instrument
• Being in company with another person or persons
• Using corporal violence on any person
• Intentionally or recklessly inflicting actual bodily harm
• Depriving a person of their liberty
• Knowing that there were people present on the premises

Aggravated break and enter offences are treated even more seriously by the courts. For example, aggravated break and enter of a dwelling with intent (s113(2)) carries a maximum penalty of 20 years imprisonment, compared to 14 years for the non-aggravated version.

If the prosecution intends to rely on aggravating circumstances for a more serious charge, they must prove those circumstances beyond reasonable doubt in addition to the base elements of the offence. This makes having an experienced criminal defence lawyer even more crucial.

Legal Consequences and Penalties

The penalties and consequences for trespass and break and enter offences in NSW can be severe, reflecting the seriousness with which the law treats these crimes. The specific penalties imposed will depend on factors such as the type of offence, the circumstances surrounding the crime, and the offender’s prior criminal history.

Penalties for Break and Enter

Break and enter offences under the Crimes Act 1900 carry some of the harshest penalties. The maximum sentences for different types of break and enter crimes are:

• Break, enter and assault with intent to murder (s110): 25 years imprisonment
• Enter dwelling house with intent to commit serious indictable offence (s111): 10 years imprisonment
• Break and enter dwelling house and commit serious indictable offence (s112): 14 years imprisonment
• Break and enter dwelling house with intent to commit serious indictable offence (s113): 14 years imprisonment

These substantial prison terms reflect the law’s view of break and enter as a major violation of personal safety and property rights. Even the least serious break and enter offence can result in a decade behind bars.

Aggravated Offence Penalties

The penalties for break and enter can be even more severe when aggravating factors are present. Aggravated offences may involve circumstances such as:

• The offender was armed with a weapon
• The offender was in the company of others
• The offender used violence or caused actual bodily harm
• The offender deprived someone of their liberty

In these aggravated cases, the maximum penalties can be increased even further:

• Aggravated break and enter of a dwelling house (s113(2)): 20 years imprisonment
• Specially aggravated break and enter (s113(3)): 25 years imprisonment

The presence of weapons, violence or multiple offenders can elevate an already serious crime into an offence that can attract decades in prison. This demonstrates the law’s strong condemnation of using force or fear in the course of a break and enter.

In summary, the potential consequences for trespass and especially break and enter in NSW are severe, with lengthy prison sentences possible even for a first offence. The specific penalty in any case will depend on the unique facts involved, but the hefty maximum penalties reflect the seriousness of these crimes in the eyes of the law. Anyone facing charges for these offences should seek experienced legal advice to protect their rights and present the strongest possible defence.

Legal Defences

When facing trespass or break and enter charges in NSW, there are several potential legal defences that may be available depending on the specific circumstances of the case. Understanding these defences is crucial for anyone accused of these offences, as they can potentially lead to an acquittal or reduction in charges.

Defences to Trespass

There are a few key defences that may apply to trespass charges under the Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901:

• Lawful Excuse: Section 4 of the Act provides that if there is a lawful excuse, proof of which lies with the person entering or remaining on the inclosed lands, that person will not be found liable for a penalty. For example, a person in charge of stock being driven on a road lawfully inclosed within the lands of any person entering those lands to prevent stock from straying, or regaining control of stock that have strayed, from the road would have a lawful excuse.
• Consent: Consent of the property owner is the most straightforward lawful excuse for trespass. If you have explicit permission to enter or remain on another’s property, you are not trespassing. This consent must be freely given and not obtained through fraud, coercion, or duress.
• Necessity: Necessity may also constitute a lawful excuse in some instances. This will require you to demonstrate to the court that you committed the crime of trespassing while responding to an immediate danger or threat or to prevent serious harm. You will have to convince the court, however, that any reasonable person in the same position would have taken a similar action.

Defences to Break and Enter

Some potential defences to break and enter charges under the Crimes Act 1900 include:

• Claim of Right: A claim of right is a defence where the accused genuinely believes they have a legal right to the property in question. This belief must be honest, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be reasonable.
• Lack of Intent: If it can be shown that the accused did not have the intent to commit a crime at the time of entry, this may serve as a defence against break and enter charges.
• Consent: Similar to trespass, if it can be demonstrated that the accused had consent to enter the premises, this may serve as a defence against break and enter charges.

Other defences like alibi, duress, necessity or self-defence may apply in certain break and enter cases depending on the specific facts.

It’s important to note that these defences are complex legal concepts, and their success depends on the specific facts of each case. Professional legal advice is crucial in determining the most appropriate defence strategy and presenting it effectively in court. If you are facing trespass or break and enter charges, it is highly advisable to seek immediate legal representation from an experienced criminal defence lawyer.

Key Differences Between Trespass and Breaking and Entering Under NSW Laws

Aspect	Trespass	Break and Enter
Governing Law	Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901	Crimes Act 1900
Definition	Unauthorised entry or remaining on inclosed lands without permission	Entering a property with intent to commit a serious indictable offence
Key Elements	– Entering inclosed lands without permission – Remaining after being asked to leave – No requirement for criminal intent	– Intent to commit a serious offence – May include forcible entry – Requires proof of criminal intent
Intent Requirement	No criminal intent required	Criminal intent required
Classification	Typically a civil offence, can be criminal in some cases	Criminal offence
Penalties	Fines or lesser penalties (may escalate with repeat offences)	Higher penalties, potentially including imprisonment
Severity	Considered less severe	Considered a more serious offence

Conclusion

Trespass and break and enter offences are distinct crimes under New South Wales law, each carrying different penalties and legal consequences. Trespass offences, governed by the Inclosed Lands Protection Act 1901, involve entering or remaining on enclosed lands without permission. These offences typically result in fines, with more severe penalties for aggravated circumstances or prescribed premises.

In contrast, break and enter offences fall under the Crimes Act 1900 and are considered more serious crimes. These offences involve entering a dwelling or premises with the intent to commit a serious indictable offence, such as theft or assault. The penalties for break and enter can include significant prison sentences, particularly when aggravating factors are present, such as the use of weapons or infliction of harm.

Given the complexity of these laws and the potential for severe consequences, it is crucial for anyone facing trespass or break and enter charges to seek experienced legal representation. A skilled criminal defence lawyer can help navigate the legal system, build a strong defence strategy, and work towards the best possible outcome in court.

Empower yourself with the right legal advice—call us now.

Frequently Asked Questions