Interactions with the police in New South Wales can feel like navigating a maze, especially if folks don’t know their rights. It’s super important for everyone to grasp what the police can and can’t do, along with the rights that apply during such encounters. Understanding these gives clarity and confidence when it counts.
This comprehensive guide aims to provide a clear overview of NSW police powers in relation to young people, detailing the rights and responsibilities of minors in various situations such as police questioning, searches, arrest, and diversion options under the Young Offenders Act. By understanding these key legal concepts, young people and their support networks can navigate interactions with the police more effectively and ensure their rights are protected.
Understanding Age of Criminal Responsibility and Police Powers in NSW
Age of Criminal Responsibility in NSW
In NSW, the age of criminal responsibility legally starts at 10 years old. This means that a child under the age of 10 cannot be arrested or charged with a criminal offence. However, once a young person turns 10, they can be held criminally responsible for their actions under the law.
It’s important for young people and their parents or guardians to understand that from the age of 10, a child’s actions may have serious legal consequences. If a young person aged 10 or older breaks the law, they can be dealt with by police, arrested, and face charges in the Children’s Court.
To learn more about the age of criminal responsibility in NSW, make sure to read our detailed article here.
Police Powers When Dealing with Young People
While police have the power to investigate crimes involving young people aged 10 and over, they are required by law to take extra precautions when interacting with minors. These additional measures are in place to protect the rights of young people and ensure they are treated fairly in the justice system.
Some key powers and responsibilities of police when dealing with young suspects include:
- Police must have a reasonable suspicion that a young person has committed a crime before they can arrest them. They cannot arrest a young person arbitrarily or without cause.
- When arresting a young person, police must inform them that they are under arrest, explain why they are being arrested, and provide their name and place of duty. The young person has the right to know this information.
- Police can ask for a young person’s name and address. If the young person refuses to provide these details, they may be committing an offence.
- If police wish to interview a young person about an alleged offence, they must have a support person present. This can be a parent, guardian, lawyer, or other responsible adult not involved in the investigation. The support person is there to ensure the young person’s rights are protected.
- Police must caution a young person that they have the right to remain silent and that anything they say may be used as evidence. The young person is not required to answer police questions during an interview.
- For less serious offences, police have the discretion to divert young offenders away from the court system. They can issue warnings, cautions, or refer the matter to a Youth Justice Conference if the young person admits to the offence.
By adhering to these special requirements, police aim to handle youth offending in a way that is age-appropriate, minimises stigma, and promotes rehabilitation wherever possible. However, in more serious cases, young people may still be arrested, charged, and required to appear before the Children’s Court to face the allegations against them.
Get Immediate Legal Help Now.
Available 24/7
Rights During Police Questioning and Interviews
Young people in NSW have specific rights when being questioned or interviewed by police. It’s crucial for both young people and their parents or guardians to understand these rights to ensure fair treatment and protect the young person’s interests.
Right to Remain Silent
Young people have the right to remain silent during police questioning, with some exceptions. They are not required to answer police questions, make a statement, or sign any documents, unless they are:
- Driving a car
- Under 18 and drinking alcohol in a public place
- Suspected of being involved in or witnessing a serious crime
- On public transport
- Involved in a car accident
In these situations, the young person must provide their name and address to the police if asked. However, in most other circumstances, they can exercise their right to silence.
Support Person Requirements
Police must follow special procedures when interviewing a young person, including having a support person present. The support person can be:
- A parent or guardian
- An adult chosen by the young person (if 14 or older) or their parent, who is independent of the police
- A lawyer chosen by the young person (if 14 or older)
- A person not involved in the investigation who has no interest in the outcome
- A Justice of the Peace (as a last resort)
The police are responsible for organising the support person and cannot proceed with the interview until they are present. Even with a support person, the young person is not required to make a statement or sign anything. If they do, it may be used as evidence in court.
Legal Advice Rights
Before any formal police interview, the young person has the right to speak with a lawyer. Police should allow them to contact the Legal Aid Youth Hotline or Aboriginal Legal Service for free legal advice.
After receiving legal advice, if the young person admits to the offence, police may give a warning, caution, or refer them to a Youth Justice Conference. In these cases, written information should be provided about the next steps.
If the young person is charged, police will issue a Court Attendance Notice (CAN). It’s important to seek further legal advice in this situation by contacting the Legal Aid Youth Hotline or Aboriginal Legal Service.
Understanding and asserting these rights is essential for protecting the interests of young people during police interactions. Parents and guardians play a vital role in supporting young people and ensuring police follow proper procedures. When in doubt, always seek legal advice from the free services available.
Police Powers of Arrest and Detention
Police have specific powers when it comes to arresting and detaining young people in NSW. It’s important for young people to understand the circumstances under which police can make an arrest and their rights during the process.
When Police Can Arrest
Police can arrest a young person if they have a reasonable suspicion that the young person has committed an offence. When making an arrest, police must:
- Inform the young person that they are under arrest
- Clearly explain the reasons for the arrest
- Provide their name and place of duty (police station)
If police fail to provide this information at the time of arrest, the young person should ask for it.
It’s important to note that struggling or running from police after an arrest has been made can lead to additional charges of resisting arrest or escaping lawful custody.
Rights During Arrest
When a young person is arrested, they have certain rights that police must respect:
- Police must take the young person to a police station as soon as reasonably practicable after the arrest.
- If under 18, a support person (parent, guardian, adult relative or independent person) must be present during any police interview or questioning. Police are responsible for arranging this before the interview can proceed.
- The young person has the right to remain silent. They do not have to answer any police questions, make a statement, or sign any documents.
- The young person has the right to speak with a lawyer before being interviewed. Police should allow contact with the Legal Aid Youth Hotline or Aboriginal Legal Service.
- If the young person admits to the offence after receiving legal advice, police may issue a warning, caution or refer the matter to a Youth Justice Conference. Written information should be provided on what happens next.
- For young people over 14, police may take identifying particulars like photographs and fingerprints. These must be destroyed if the court dismisses the charges.
After an arrest, police will decide whether to grant bail (release) until the court date or to keep the young person in custody. If bail is refused, the young person can be held on remand in a youth detention centre until appearing before a court.
Understanding these police powers and individual rights is crucial for young people who come into contact with the law. Seeking legal advice at the earliest opportunity is always recommended to protect their interests during the arrest and detention process.
Speak to a Lawyer Today.
Available 24/7
Diversion Options Under the Young Offenders Act
The Young Offenders Act 1997 provides police with options to divert eligible young offenders away from formal court proceedings. These diversionary measures aim to keep young people out of detention and reduce their likelihood of reoffending. Police may offer warnings, cautions, or referrals to youth justice conferencing if the young person admits to the offence and consents to the diversion.
Warnings and Cautions
For minor offences, police can issue a warning to a young person at any place without conditions or additional sanctions. The warning is recorded by police, who may also notify the young person’s parents.
A caution is a more formal warning that can only be given if the young person admits the offence and agrees to the caution. Police consider factors such as the seriousness of the offence, the degree of violence involved, harm caused to any victim, and the young person’s prior offending history when determining whether a caution is appropriate.
The young person must sign a caution notice outlining the offence details and the purpose of the caution for it to be valid. Cautions serve as an official record but allow the young person to avoid going through the court system.
Youth Justice Conferencing
For more serious offences, police or the Children’s Court may refer the matter to a youth justice conference. This process brings together the young offender, their family, and the victim(s) to discuss the crime’s impact and develop a plan to make amends and prevent future offending.
Youth justice conferencing is available when the young person admits to the offence and agrees to participate. The conference may result in the young person apologising, paying reparations, or agreeing to undertake steps to address their behaviour, such as counselling, community service, or educational programs.
Conferencing provides a restorative justice approach, focusing on the young person taking responsibility for their actions, repairing the harm caused to victims, and reintegrating positively into the community. Successful completion of the conference plan allows the young person to avoid a formal conviction and criminal record.
If a young person is not diverted or the diversionary options are unsuccessful, they will face formal charges in the Children’s Court. However, the Young Offenders Act emphasises diversion as a key strategy to intervene early, address the underlying causes of offending, and give young people opportunities to learn from their mistakes without the stigma of a court conviction. Police play a crucial role in determining when diversion is suitable and guiding young offenders towards these alternative pathways.
Conclusion
Understanding your rights when dealing with police is crucial for all young people in NSW. This guide has provided an overview of the key areas where police interact with youth, including questioning, searches, arrest, and diversion options.
It’s important to remember that while police have certain powers, young people also have rights that protect them. Knowing these rights can help ensure fair treatment and prevent unnecessary escalation of situations. If you’re ever unsure about your rights or feel they have been violated, don’t hesitate to seek legal advice from services like the Legal Aid Youth Hotline.
By being informed and assertive about your rights, you can navigate interactions with police more effectively. Share this knowledge with your peers and encourage open discussions about these issues. Together, we can work towards building a society where the rights of all young people are respected and upheld.